Manyuan LongEdna K Papazian Distinguished Service Professor, The University of Chicago
- The University of Chicago
- United States of America
About Manyuan Long
Channels contributed to:Behind the Paper
As I commented briefly in a blog of the nature ecology evolution research community (March 26, 2019), our recent paper in Nature Ecology and Evolution (Zhang et al, 2019) and the other one in Nature Ecology & Evolution (Vankuren and Long, 2018) received excellent reviews, definitely among the top 5 papers that received the best reviews in my career (the other three including Zhang et al (2011, PLoS Biology), Zhang et al (2004. PNAS) , Long and Langley (1993, Science). I use the words “excellent” and “best”, not because those reviewers endorsed or editors accepted our papers but their high standard of scientific researches, professional levels in the related fields and publication, and their roles in improvement of these papers in science and presentation. Some of these reviewers were so generous and even participated in further analyses of the data we presented in those manuscripts, generated significant results and encouraged us to use in the manuscripts.
For example, our 2018 paper in Nature Ecology & Evolution is such an example, in which a reviewer pointed out an additional candidate gene duplication for resolving sexual conflict, promoting us to do further analyses in other Drosophila lineages. We found additional two more candidates. We are grateful to this reviewer but regretted we even could not mention his or her name in the acknowledgement because, for an understandable reason, the editorial rules of Nature Ecology and Evolution did not share with us the names of reviewers and did not allow us to say a Thank You to the reviewer in the end of the paper. I wish these anonymous reviewers would know our gratitude to their hard work and generosity with their critical comments, which contribute to a beauty of intellectual life in the world of scientists.